How the Left Accidentally Bolstered the Nativist Right

By dismissing the distinction between legal and illegal immigration as bogus, advocates signaled that they would not defend it.

How the Left Accidentally Bolstered the Nativist Right

TL;DR

  • Major conservative institutions and politicians are now openly questioning or seeking to reduce legal immigration, a shift from past norms.
  • Some left-leaning advocates and scholars argue that all immigration restrictions are indefensible, abandoning the legal/illegal distinction.
  • The traditional view held that legal and illegal immigration were distinct, allowing support for one while opposing the other.
  • This distinction reflected a public belief in opposing unlawful activity as a matter of principle.
  • Scholars and advocates increasingly view the distinction as illegitimate, arguing the U.S. immigration system is already too restrictive.
  • Media organizations and advocacy groups have largely dropped the term 'illegal immigrant' in favor of 'undocumented.'
  • The Trump administration's policies and rhetoric have further eroded the distinction, making attacks on legal immigration more acceptable.
  • The left's dismissal of the legal/illegal distinction unintentionally made it easier for the nativist right to advance its agenda.
  • Rebuilding a viable immigration-reform coalition requires acknowledging the negative consequences of illegal immigration and focusing on creating a functional legal system.