Iran Could Speedrun the Vietnamese Path
The prediction that Iran will be America’s next Vietnam—a moral catastrophe, an abyss into which money and lives have been pitched, with the sole effect of weakening the United States and heartening its enemies—is already in general circulation among Americans. A few days ago, the Iranian embassy in Hanoi joined the doomsaying. Its X account featured an AI-generated image of a mouth-breathing American GI being lectured to by a smiling Vietnamese soldier in Saigon on April 30, 1975. “We thought that after the Vietnam War, you would never invade any country again,” the soldier says. “It seems that after 50 years you have forgotten that devastating defeat.”
TL;DR
- An AI-generated image from the Iranian embassy in Vietnam suggests a parallel between Iran's potential conflict with the US and the Vietnam War.
- Modern Vietnam, once a symbol of US defeat, has embraced market economics and global trade, even partnering strategically with the US.
- The article outlines a four-step scenario for Iran's conflict, similar to Vietnam's, suggesting steps 3 and 4 (US withdrawal and post-war destruction) may still occur.
- Experts suggest that post-war authoritarianism in Vietnam strengthened, a trend mirrored in Iran.
- Vietnam's path to reconciliation with the US was delayed by geopolitical factors and isolation, but economic reforms eventually led to growth.
- Iran faces significant pre-existing challenges (economic catastrophe, ecological collapse, isolation) that could be exacerbated by conflict.
- A key difference is that Vietnam's goal was national independence, while Iran's might be revolutionary Shiite Islamism, potentially hindering pragmatic change.
- If Iran remains unwilling to accept a 'win' and move on, it risks self-destruction, unlike Vietnam which eventually transitioned.
- The article questions if Iran's leaders possess the pragmatic streak needed to follow Vietnam's path to recovery and pro-Americanism.