‘A surrender to special interests’: alarm as Utah shields fossil-fuel companies
New legislation comes amid push from big oil, as critics warn polluters’ profits prioritized over Americans’ health

TL;DR
- Utah's new law shields entities from liability for climate damages unless a specific "enforceable limitation" or "valid permit" is violated, requiring "clear and convincing evidence" of direct harm.
- This legislation is part of a larger push by the fossil fuel industry and associated groups for legal immunity, similar to the waiver granted to the firearms industry.
- Critics, including scientists and environmental advocates, describe the law as a "surrender to wealthy special interests" that prioritizes polluters' profits over communities affected by climate impacts.
- Similar legislation is being considered or has passed in other Republican-led states, including Louisiana, Oklahoma, Iowa, and Tennessee.
- The model for Utah's law appears to be the "Energy Freedom Act," circulated by the conservative group Consumers Defense, which has ties to groups linked to Leonard Leo.
- Fossil fuel companies and their allies argue such laws are necessary to prevent "frivolous" lawsuits and to ensure climate policy is decided by elected lawmakers, not through litigation.
- This push for immunity comes as numerous climate lawsuits against energy majors are advancing, and states like New York and Vermont are enacting laws to hold polluters financially responsible for damages.
- The strategy mirrors past efforts by the firearms, pesticide, and tobacco industries to seek liability waivers, with mixed success.