Ex-CIA analyst David McCloskey on the Mossad’s intelligence inside Iran: ‘I was surprised’

The podcast host and author of The Persian reflects on why Israel’s precision in Iran caught him off guard

Ex-CIA analyst David McCloskey on the Mossad’s intelligence inside Iran: ‘I was surprised’

TL;DR

  • David McCloskey, a former CIA analyst and author, was surprised by reports of the CIA providing intelligence for the assassination of Ayatollah Khamenei in Iran.
  • McCloskey believes Israel's Mossad has significantly more advanced capabilities for intelligence gathering and operations within Iran compared to the CIA.
  • He attributes Israel's success to its deep societal penetration and a strategic, existential focus on Iran.
  • Iran's large size and societal 'seams and fissures' make it a vulnerable target for intelligence agencies.
  • Israel possesses linguistic and cultural advantages due to its Farsi-speaking Persian Jewish diaspora, which aids its operations in Iran.
  • The CIA's efforts are hampered by factors like security clearance rules and a perceived lack of strategic urgency compared to Israel's approach.