The era of amateur Vaticanology dawns in the United States

Vaticanology, the practice of studying and writing about the inner workings of the Holy See, was a niche area of journalism for most of American history.

The era of amateur Vaticanology dawns in the United States

TL;DR

  • Vaticanology, the study of the Holy See, has become a popular, often amateur, genre in American journalism.
  • A report of a meeting between Elbridge Colby and Cardinal Christophe Pierre was sensationalized and distorted by various media outlets.
  • These exaggerated reports claimed the U.S. government delivered a 'bitter lecture' and made threats against the Vatican.
  • Blogs run by political operatives further amplified and distorted the narrative, accusing 'anti-Catholic operatives' of a plot.
  • Both the Department of War and the Vatican have issued statements refuting the sensationalized reporting, calling it 'grossly false and distorted' and 'completely untrue'.
  • Cardinal Pierre himself described the stories as 'fabrications' invented by journalists.
  • The Vatican's shift from its usual 'never complain, never explain' approach indicates the severity of the misinformation.
  • The article suggests this trend marks a new, challenging era for Vatican reporting, moving away from established journalistic practices.