A Failed Test of Leadership

Bad things happen in war. Deflecting blame makes everything worse.

A Failed Test of Leadership

TL;DR

  • War inherently involves tragic mistakes, including civilian deaths, which have historically occurred even with disciplined militaries.
  • Denying obvious responsibility for mistakes, such as a U.S. bombing of an Iranian school, undermines credibility and signals insecurity.
  • Acknowledging mistakes in war demonstrates confidence and strengthens a nation's credibility and moral authority.
  • Historical examples show that U.S. leaders have acknowledged tragic errors in past conflicts, such as the My Lai massacre, the USS Vincennes incident, and the bombing of the Chinese embassy.
  • Admitting errors reinforces the truth that American power relies on credibility and moral authority, not just military strength.
  • The character of a leader is tested by their response to failure, and democracies should investigate and acknowledge mistakes, unlike authoritarian regimes.