Don’t look at who voted to call the slave trade ‘the gravest crime’, look at who didn’t

The UK and EU countries who abstained when Ghana’s UN resolution was adopted may soon find it harder to sustain the same old script on reparations

Don’t look at who voted to call the slave trade ‘the gravest crime’, look at who didn’t

TL;DR

  • A UN resolution led by Ghana declared the trafficking and racialized chattel enslavement of Africans "the gravest crime against humanity," passing with 123 votes in favor.
  • The US, Israel, and Argentina voted against the resolution, while the UK and all EU member states abstained, highlighting a global division on acknowledging historical injustices.
  • Objections from the UK and EU, citing legal caution and the creation of a "hierarchy of historical atrocities," are criticized as attempts to avoid confronting the enduring consequences of transatlantic slavery.
  • The article contends that these objections represent a strategy of "historical laundering" by former slave-trading powers, profiting from the crime while seeking moral credit for its abolition.
  • The resolution is seen as a vital first step in establishing a framework for reparations, moving the discussion from the margins to the center and challenging the historical amnesia surrounding slavery's role in global wealth.
  • Caricom's 10-point plan for reparatory justice is highlighted for linking formal apologies to tangible development initiatives, treating slavery as a generator of ongoing harm.
  • The fear of Western nations regarding the resolution stems from its potential to create precedent, leading to further questions about debt, underdevelopment, and historical compensation.
  • The abstentions from countries with imperial histories, like Ireland, are seen as a failure to connect historical memory with contemporary responsibility.
  • The article concludes that the resolution exposed those who wish for the wealth from slavery to remain forgotten and serves as a reminder that justice delayed is not justice denied.