The US-Israel relationship is finally facing a reckoning. It doesn't need to slide into antisemitism

Israel’s role in drawing the US into a war on Iran is attracting healthy scrutiny. It’s also creating a permission structure for antisemitism

The US-Israel relationship is finally facing a reckoning. It doesn't need to slide into antisemitism

TL;DR

  • Joint US-Israel military strikes on Iran have forced a reckoning in American political culture concerning the US-Israel relationship.
  • Legitimate questions are being raised about Israel's role in shaping US military timing and decision-making, with concerns about intelligence sharing and lobbying pressure.
  • Public opinion polls indicate a decline in American sympathy for Israel, with critiques emerging from across the political spectrum.
  • The increased acceptability of criticism of Israel is creating a 'permission structure' for greater antisemitism.
  • Antisemitic tropes and conspiracy theories, such as 'puppet masters' and 'dual loyalties,' are surging on social media.
  • The article advocates for simultaneously criticizing Israeli policy as if antisemitism did not exist, and fighting antisemitism as if the state of Israel did not exist.
  • Navigating this moment requires holding both commitments without letting either moderate the other, making fine distinctions in unpopular circumstances.
  • The text criticizes figures who use genuine concerns about US foreign policy towards Israel to attract followers, while promoting bigotry or Holocaust revisionism.
  • Maintaining democratic accountability and societal decency requires avoiding the sacrifice of either.