'Nobody would forgive me if I told the truth': new film about pacifist turned Nazi collaborator divides France

In Les Rayons et les Ombres, Jean Dujardin plays a real-life press baron partying during the horrors of the second world war. Director Xavier Giannoli discusses bringing this still sensitive topic to light

'Nobody would forgive me if I told the truth': new film about pacifist turned Nazi collaborator divides France

TL;DR

  • The film "Rays and Shadows" by Xavier Giannoli focuses on Corinne Luchaire and her father Jean Luchaire, a press baron who collaborated with the Nazis.
  • Corinne Luchaire's post-war perspective reveals her struggle to reconcile her devotion to her father with his execution for treason.
  • The film has divided critics, with some hailing it as a masterpiece of historical nuance and others criticizing its portrayal of collaborators.
  • Director Giannoli intended to show how personal fears and cowardice can influence historical events.
  • The film controversially depicts Jean Luchaire as a spendthrift rather than a committed ideologue, exploring his relationship with Nazi official Otto Abetz.
  • Giannoli highlights the "bohemian" atmosphere cultivated by Abetz to seduce French elites into collaboration.
  • The film doesn't shy away from depicting the decadent lifestyle of collaborators, featuring scenes of lavish parties and orgies.
  • Historians like Laurent Joly question the film's depiction of Jean Luchaire's motivations, suggesting amorality and venality over pacifism, and also find the portrayal of Corinne Luchaire as a pitiful victim exaggerated.
  • Giannoli aimed for a balance between "fascination and indignation" when portraying these historical figures and events.