Smirking Past the Gallows

An ugly law backed by Itamar Ben-Gvir might never be applied—but it will still do real damage.

Smirking Past the Gallows

TL;DR

  • Israel's Knesset passed a law allowing the death penalty for convicted terrorists by a 62-48 vote.
  • The law is expected to be challenged in the Israeli supreme court and potentially struck down.
  • The law applies only to residents of the West Bank under Israeli military courts, exempting Israeli citizens.
  • Enforcement may be limited by a requirement to prove intent to deny Israel's existence and a "special circumstances" waiver.
  • Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu supported the bill after previously opposing it, a tactic seen as blaming liberal judges if it fails.
  • The law's passage is partly due to the genuine Israeli dilemma of deterring terrorism, with failed diplomatic compromises and prisoner releases leading to further attacks.
  • Critics argue the law will deepen the incentive for terrorist murders, embitter Palestinians, harm Israel's international reputation, and create a perception of cheap Palestinian blood.
  • Security professionals, including from Shin Bet, oppose the law, fearing it will lead to more severe violence.
  • Despite the law, terrorism is expected to continue, and the high court will likely strike down the legislation.