Trump’s Absurd Citizenship Arguments Went Nowhere
As the Supreme Court heard oral arguments today about birthright citizenship, Donald Trump was watching from the courtroom—an apparent first for a sitting president. He listened silently as the justices pelted skeptical questions at Solicitor General John Sauer, who tried to defend a Trump executive order purporting to deny citizenship to the U.S.-born children of certain immigrants. Not long into arguments by Cecillia Wang, the ACLU lawyer representing Trump’s challengers, the president got up and left.
TL;DR
- Donald Trump attended oral arguments at the Supreme Court on birthright citizenship, an unusual presence for a sitting president.
- The case, *Trump v. Barbara*, concerns a Trump administration executive order attempting to deny citizenship to U.S.-born children of certain immigrants, challenging the established meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment.
- Most Supreme Court justices, including conservatives, expressed skepticism towards the administration's arguments, questioning the interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment and citing the precedent set in *United States v. Wong Kim Ark*.
- Solicitor General John Sauer's arguments were met with critical questions from justices like Roberts, Gorsuch, and Barrett.
- ACLU lawyer Cecillia Wang, representing the challengers, faced a more receptive audience, with Justice Kavanaugh suggesting a straightforward ruling in her favor.
- The article suggests the Court is likely to uphold birthright citizenship, but criticizes the administration and legal scholars for pursuing arguments against the Fourteenth Amendment.