ICE Might Be Violating America’s Other Bill of Rights

To keep rogue agents in check, we need to look beyond the Constitution.

ICE Might Be Violating America’s Other Bill of Rights

TL;DR

  • Immigration enforcement officers have allegedly engaged in misconduct, prompting legal challenges often based on the Fourth Amendment.
  • Supreme Court rulings have weakened the Fourth Amendment's application against ICE and CBP, impacting deportation proceedings and lawsuits over excessive force.
  • The Administrative Procedure Act (APA) offers a potential legal avenue to hold federal agencies like the Department of Homeland Security accountable for unlawful actions.
  • Focusing lawsuits on the APA and an agency's decision-making process, rather than solely on the unconstitutionality of actions, may lead to greater success.
  • Past cases, such as *Accardi v. Shaughnessy* and *Sanchez v. Sessions*, demonstrate how administrative law principles can be used to challenge agency misconduct and ensure adherence to their own regulations.
  • Recent Supreme Court decisions have increased judicial oversight of federal agencies, providing a basis for reining in ICE's behavior.
  • The APA allows advocates to slow down immigration bureaucracy, potentially keeping families together and allowing asylum seekers to build lives.