Trump admin faces tough questions on birthright citizenship at Supreme Court

Supreme Court justices grilled the Trump administration over its executive order on birthright citizenship on Wednesday, appearing skeptical of the arguments by the solicitor general that birthright citizenship should not apply to the children of illegal immigrants or temporary visitors.

Trump admin faces tough questions on birthright citizenship at Supreme Court

TL;DR

  • Supreme Court justices grilled the Trump administration regarding an executive order challenging birthright citizenship.
  • Justices appeared skeptical of arguments that birthright citizenship should not apply to children of illegal immigrants or temporary visitors.
  • Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued that 'subject to the jurisdiction' excludes children of non-citizens.
  • Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kagan questioned the DOJ's use of obscure sources and broad exclusions.
  • Justice Thomas questioned the relevance of immigration concerns to the 14th Amendment's creation.
  • The administration cited 'birth tourism' and the U.S. as an outlier in birthright citizenship standards.
  • Justices Roberts and Kavanaugh questioned the relevance of 'birth tourism' and other countries' laws.
  • President Trump attended the oral arguments, the first known instance of a sitting president doing so.
  • Justices also questioned the ACLU's arguments, with Justice Alito focusing on the relevance of domicile in past rulings.
  • A ruling in the case is expected by the end of June.