Washington can’t become America's bookie

Betting on elections and economic data may be the newest frontier in “finance,” but it is still gambling. And while Congress has the power under the commerce clause to regulate that interstate activity, it has not clearly handed the Commodity Futures Trading Commission a blank check to bulldoze 50 states’ gambling regulatory regimes in the name of “exclusive jurisdiction” over prediction markets.

Washington can’t become America's bookie

TL;DR

  • Prediction markets, like Kalshi, are functionally similar to sportsbooks, facilitating bets on various events and generating substantial fees.
  • The expansion of prediction markets and app-based sports betting has been linked to increased gambling-disorder helpline calls.
  • States have established regulatory frameworks for commercial gambling, including licensing, oversight, and age verification, which prediction markets may circumvent if under CFTC jurisdiction.
  • The CFTC claims exclusive jurisdiction over certain markets based on the Commodity Exchange Act, but this is being challenged in court.
  • Recent court rulings have shown skepticism towards the CFTC's broad interpretation of its authority, emphasizing the need for clear congressional legislation.
  • Congress has the power to create a national framework for prediction markets or expressly preempt state gambling laws, but this has not yet occurred.