How Trump’s EPA rollbacks give US states new tools in climate suits

Vermont and New York face high stakes to protect climate superfund laws as it faces attacks from Trump’s DoJ

How Trump’s EPA rollbacks give US states new tools in climate suits

TL;DR

  • Green groups assert that the Trump administration's repeal of the EPA's endangerment finding strengthens states' ability to enact climate accountability laws.
  • The administration is attempting to block Vermont's 'climate superfund' law, arguing federal law preempts state regulation of greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Critics point out the contradiction in the administration's stance: claiming federal authority precludes state action while simultaneously arguing it lacks authority to regulate emissions.
  • The repeal of the endangerment finding is expected to be a significant factor in defending state climate laws and numerous climate lawsuits against fossil fuel companies.
  • New York's Attorney General is also defending similar 'climate superfund' laws, using the same legal reasoning.
  • The EPA claims the repeal applies only to motor vehicle emissions and that the Clean Air Act still preempts state laws, but experts disagree, stating it removes federal authority over stationary sources as well.
  • Vermont's law focuses on costs for past emissions, not direct control of future emissions, further weakening the preemption argument.
  • The fight to protect climate superfund laws is seen as critical, especially as federal leaders are perceived to lack a coherent climate crisis plan.
  • Other states are considering similar climate superfund policies.
  • The impact of the endangerment finding repeal could also affect climate accountability litigation against major oil companies.