US lower court judges are challenging Trump’s ‘war on the rule of law’, experts say

Impact of rulings by these judges has been sizable, slowing or halting some of the president’s most extreme policies

US lower court judges are challenging Trump’s ‘war on the rule of law’, experts say

TL;DR

  • Lower federal court judges are issuing critical rulings against many of Donald Trump's policies and executive actions.
  • These rulings have temporarily blocked key policies, particularly in areas of immigration, tariffs, and DOJ prosecutions.
  • Trump and his allies have responded with public attacks on judges, which have reportedly fueled threats against them.
  • Legal experts and former DOJ officials see these judges as a vital check on presidential power and a defense of the rule of law.
  • A study by Just Security found over 210 cases since early 2025 where courts issued strong rulings against administration conduct.
  • Several judges, appointed by both Republican and Democratic presidents, have been outspoken critics and have faced direct attacks from Trump.
  • The increase in adverse rulings has led the administration to push for emergency appeals to the Supreme Court.
  • Some former judges express concern about the toxic courtroom climate and the rise in threats against judges.