Three exchanges show why Trump will lose the birthright citizenship case

It is not surprising that the three liberal justices on the Supreme Court were antagonistic toward President Donald Trump’s Solicitor General John Sauer during oral argument in Trump v. Barbara on Wednesday, nor were some of the softballs tossed Sauer’s way by Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Brett Kavanaugh.

Three exchanges show why Trump will lose the birthright citizenship case

TL;DR

  • Solicitor General John Sauer's argument in *Trump v. Barbara* did not directly challenge the precedent set by *United States v. Wong Kim Ark*.
  • Sauer attempted to limit the definition of natural born citizenship by introducing concepts of 'lawful presence' and 'intent to remain permanently', which were questioned by justices.
  • Justice Gorsuch pointed out that the legal understanding of 'domiciled resident' in 1868 differed from modern immigration laws.
  • Justice Barrett questioned how Sauer's theory of 'intent' would practically be adjudicated.
  • Chief Justice Roberts challenged the relevance of 'birth tourism' arguments, stating that the Constitution remains the same despite new developments.
  • The core of the case involves applying contemporary immigration law interpretations to the 14th Amendment, a strategy the justices found legally unsound.