Why Populists Are Winning and How to Beat Them by Liam Byrne review

A former New Labour minister tackles the question of our times with rigour and verve – but blindspots remain

Why Populists Are Winning and How to Beat Them by Liam Byrne review

TL;DR

  • Liam Byrne, a former New Labour minister, has written a book analyzing the rise of rightwing populism and how to counter it.
  • The book is seen as an attempt by Byrne to atone for his past political actions, particularly the "no money" letter that contributed to public disillusionment.
  • Byrne's analysis often echoes centrist viewpoints, suggesting respect for populist voters as a strategy, which the review deems ineffective given the current political landscape.
  • The book identifies paradoxes within populism, such as its anti-elite stance while being led by the wealthy and its espousal of freedom alongside authoritarian policies.
  • Byrne analyzes the clear and conversational language used by populists like Nigel Farage, contrasting it with the "word salads" of conventional politicians.
  • The review criticizes the book for treating populism as exclusively rightwing, neglecting leftwing populism and the potential role of the radical left in opposing it.
  • A key criticism is that the book downplays the role of increasing economic inequality in populism's rise, a factor uncomfortable for mainstream elites.
  • Byrne proposes solutions such as exposing populist leaders more aggressively, tightening political funding laws, and increasing taxes on the wealthy.
  • The review suggests Byrne's remedies might not fully 'beat' populism but could reduce its electoral success, offering time for alternative solutions.