Democratic judge under fire for releasing violent offenders calls bail law a ‘direct assault’ on rights

Judge David Carpenter called Alabama’s Aniah’s Law a ‘direct assault’ on constitutional rights, citing defendants’ presumption of innocence.

Democratic judge under fire for releasing violent offenders calls bail law a ‘direct assault’ on rights

TL;DR

  • Circuit Court Judge David Carpenter calls Alabama's Aniah's Law, which allows denial of bail for certain violent crimes, an "assault on constitutional rights."
  • Carpenter argues that defendants should not be held indefinitely based solely on charges, citing the presumption of innocence.
  • He contrasts the public's concern over surveillance cameras with their silence on expanded pretrial detention laws.
  • Carpenter has been criticized for releasing offenders who have allegedly committed further violent crimes after their release.
  • Examples include approving a plea deal for a man arrested for shooting two people as a minor, who later allegedly killed 18 people, and granting bond to an individual charged with murder who then allegedly killed three more people.
  • He also dismissed a rape charge against a man who later met Paighton Houston, who disappeared and died of an overdose; the man pleaded guilty to abuse of a corpse and received a split sentence.
  • Houston's mother asked the Alabama Attorney General to investigate Carpenter's decision.
  • Carpenter's campaign platform included reforming the criminal justice system and reducing repeat offenders.