I Don't Know How the War Is Going
Cheering for epistemic humility gets you no television interviews, no requests for op-eds, and no invitations to conferences. All that it will earn you is a fair bit of social-media critique for being a wimp, a sellout, or a garden-variety fool. But in the early phase of a war, above all, it should be the prudent observer’s battle cry.
TL;DR
- Epistemic humility is essential in the early phase of a war, cautioning against simplistic analogies and historical shortcuts.
- Comparing the current conflict to the Iraq War is a flawed cognitive shortcut, as the Trump administration aims to avoid past mistakes.
- Initial missile attacks and casualties, while serious, are inevitable consequences of war and not necessarily indicators of defeat.
- Assessing war success requires evaluating complex factors like missile launch rates, target effectiveness, and leadership impact.
- The effectiveness of modern air power is continuously evolving and should not be judged solely by historical precedents.
- Disregard for political leaders should not impair objective assessment of military operations.
- Each war is unique and must be understood on its own terms, acknowledging contingent events and uncertain outcomes.
- Valuable historical insights come from asking 'How is this different?' and 'Where did this come from?' rather than seeking eternal verities.
- Broader questions about geopolitical influence, regional stability, and the reputation of military power are more important than immediate outcomes.
- Ultimately, acknowledging uncertainty about the war's progress is more accurate than insisting on definitive knowledge.