Story
Nov 15, 2026
Meta Says Italy’s €805 Million Privacy Fine Punishes a Simple Photo-Sharing Feature
Italy says Meta’s Facebook app accessed photos and videos without clear, specific consent, affecting about 20 million Android users. Meta argues users control the permission and plans to appeal.
Italy’s €805 million fine against Meta turns on a deceptively small question: whether permission to use a Facebook feature also amounted to informed consent for the app to access a user’s photo gallery. Regulators see a privacy violation at scale; Meta says the feature was optional and the penalty excessive.
Italy’s data protection agency says Facebook’s Android app accessed users’ photos and videos through a feature that suggests gallery content for posts, without adequately informing users or securing specific consent. The authority says about 20 million people in Italy were affected and has ordered Meta to disable the feature by default and seek separate consent within 60 days.1
Meta disputes that account. The company says users must grant device-level permission before the feature can work and can revoke it in settings. A spokesperson called it “a simple feature that helps people share photos and videos on Facebook” and said Meta would appeal, describing the fine as “disproportionate.”1
The dispute is less about whether the app sought access than about whether its request made the purpose clear. Italy’s regulator says the app used a single authorization for the whole service, preceded by a generic notice; users could not tell they were also enabling gallery suggestions. It says Meta must explain what access is for and how to turn it off.2 Meta’s emphasis on device permissions, by contrast, frames control as a user choice rather than a question of how clearly that choice was presented.
The regulator says the fine reflects the number of users, the duration of the practice and Meta’s lack of cooperation. It amounts to roughly 0.4% of the company’s annual turnover, according to one account; another puts it at 0.47%.21 The case also sits amid wider scrutiny of Meta’s privacy practices: a separate New Mexico jury verdict led to a $25 billion order against the company, which disputed that ruling.3