Story
Nov 20, 2026

The DOJ dropped its Alaska election challenge, but the fight is not over.

After Mary Peltola’s victory, the Trump Justice Department says its challenge to Alaska’s Senate result is moot. Critics say the case never explained how alleged voter confusion could be investigated without violating ballot secrecy, while a separate criminal probe continues.

The Trump Justice Department is stepping back from its bid to block certification of Alaska’s Senate result—but the dispute over a same-name challenger and alleged voter confusion is far from settled. After Democrat Mary Peltola won, the department asked an appeals court to declare its lawsuit moot and vacate the lower court’s dismissal.

The challenge centered on a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan, whom the DOJ argued could be confused with Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan. The department sought a post-election investigation into whether votes for the second Sullivan were intended for the senator. Peltola won with 50.13% of the vote, more than the combined total for her opponents, according to one account; the Alaska Supreme Court had already ruled the second Sullivan could remain on the ballot.

The administration’s critics have focused on a different weakness: how could officials determine voters’ intent while keeping ballots secret? The federal judge who dismissed the case said the government had not explained how its proposed remedy could address its alleged injury without compromising ballot secrecy: “The Court cannot grant the United States the relief it seeks.” A conservative account, by contrast, emphasizes the DOJ’s claims that the second candidate’s campaign materials resembled the senator’s and that Democratic operatives may have recruited him to confuse voters. Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee deny wrongdoing.

The accounts also differ on what the DOJ’s latest move means. The department says the case is moot now that the election is decided, but it has asked the appeals court to vacate the lower court’s ruling as well as dismiss the suit. That does not end the separate criminal investigation: the conservative report says investigators have issued more than 200 subpoenas. So the court challenge may be winding down, even as scrutiny of the alleged recruitment effort continues.