Story
Nov 21, 2026
A murder plot ends in prison, but questions about India remain
Nikhil Gupta received more than 19 years for his role in a foiled plot to kill Sikh activist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun. The case’s criminal verdict has not resolved the dispute over alleged links to an Indian government official.
Nikhil Gupta’s sentence closes one chapter in a foiled plot to kill Sikh separatist leader Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, but leaves a wider dispute unresolved: prosecutors tied the scheme to an Indian government official, while India has denied state involvement.
The sentencing offers two distinct frames. One headline presents the case primarily as a criminal punishment: a man received 19½ years for plotting to kill a Sikh leader in New York.1 A more expansive account emphasizes the alleged government connection and the strain the plot has placed on relations between Washington and New Delhi.2
Gupta, 55, was sentenced to 235 months after pleading guilty to murder-for-hire and related charges. Prosecutors said he worked with Indian official Vikash Yadav to arrange a $15,000 payment to a supposed hitman who was, in fact, an undercover U.S. officer. Yadav has also been charged but is not in U.S. custody. India has said that any plot against Pannun would run counter to government policy.2
The case also pits the U.S. government’s account of a threat to political expression against India’s denial of official responsibility. “We don’t condone the use of violence to silence voices in this country, ever,” prosecutor Ashley Nicolas told the court.2 Gupta apologized to Pannun, the communities he said he hurt and his family, and said he regretted straying from Mahatma Gandhi’s non-violent example.2
Pannun, who advocates for an independent Sikh state in northern India, said he would continue his campaign. The sentence establishes Gupta’s punishment; it does not settle the questions surrounding Yadav’s alleged role or the Indian government’s denials.