Story
Nov 22, 2026
A proxy-voting ruling puts pregnancy protections on uncertain ground
A divided appeals court said pandemic-era House proxy voting violated the Constitution, blocking enforcement of a pregnant workers’ law in three states. The ruling’s narrow scope contrasts with warnings that it could invite wider challenges.
A constitutional fight over how Congress conducted business during the pandemic has put protections for pregnant workers at risk in three states—and raised questions about whether other laws passed during the same period could face challenges.
The Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that House members’ proxy votes could not count toward a quorum when Congress passed the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act as part of a 2022 spending bill. The decision blocks the law’s enforcement in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, rather than invalidating it nationwide.1 The law requires employers to provide accommodations such as bathroom breaks, relief from heavy lifting and time off for prenatal appointments.1
The court’s majority treated the dispute as a question of constitutional procedure, concluding that members must be physically present to establish a quorum. The liberal article likewise reported the court’s view that “Proxy presence” does not count, but framed the ruling as a repudiation of Nancy Pelosi’s pandemic-era voting system and suggested it could open the door to challenges against other Biden-era laws.2 That broader possibility remains distinct from the ruling itself: the article says the judgment applies to Texas’ challenge to the workers’ law, even as it warns of potential challenges to the spending package.2
The conservative account foregrounded the practical consequences for workers, quoting A Better Balance President Inimai Chettiar’s warning that the ruling “could force countless women out of the workforce.”1 It also noted that Sen. Mitch McConnell supported upholding the law and that dissenting judges questioned why Texas could challenge the statute after accepting funds from the same spending act.1
The split is revealing: one account casts the case chiefly as a constitutional rebuke to Pelosi’s voting rules; the other emphasizes the cost to workers and the dissent’s challenge to Texas’ position. The ruling’s immediate reach is limited, but its appeal could determine whether the procedural dispute stays narrow or becomes a wider test of pandemic-era legislation.